Talk about The One That Got Away…
Most of the lovesick, not-too-internet-savvy hopefuls who appear on Catfish are usually pining over someone suspiciously out of their league.
That's right! According to Spencer, he and the pop superstar have been in an online relationship for the past 6 years — exchanging plenty of "I love yous" along the way.
In fact, Spencer and "Katy" are so smitten with each other, he doesn't mind that the Rise songstress is off having romantic rendezvous with "the elf from Lord of the Rings" (yes, he means Orlando Bloom) — and has already made her an engagement ring using his great-grandmother's emerald!
Yikes! This ending is gonna hurt to watch!
Ch-ch-check out the opening of one the most excruciating episodes we've ever seen (below)!