We just don't know what to think…
We've been tricked before, but ABC Family has been promising for weeks that during Tuesday night's fifth season finale, they'd finally reveal who Big A is on Pretty Little Liars.
There have been literally five years for fans to theorize over who they think could be responsible for torturing Emily, Hanna, Spencer, and Aria, so at this point, anything is possible.
So, we decided to help you out a little before the new episode, and put together a list of all the plausible identities for Big A!
Tags: abc family, lucy hale, pll, pretty little liars, tv news