Well she did fall for one of her co-stars in the scene but what we got wrong was that it wasn't Justin Theroux.
It was the goat!
"I fell in love with our goat! When we were doing our screen test, I met that goat.
I had never milked a goat in my life … I grew up in New York City."
She's clearly an animal lover which we love about her.
Apparently she even snuck a photo of her and her two dogs and put it in a frame in one of the movie's sets.
[Image via Mavrix Online.]