What What? South Park Wins Copyright Case, Accuser Forced To Pay Up

“I said What, What?”

In 2008, South Park featured Samwell‘s What What in one of their episodes.

The character Butters is featured as a parody of the music video.

The owners of lewd original, Brownmark, then sued South Park for infringing on their copyright.

South Park and its owner, Viacom, were not worried.

Their defense rested in the fair use policy and it was sound.

Even though Brownmark was told that South Park’s use of the video was fair, the small company did so anyway.

The result?

A Wisconsin judge immediately dismissed the case, punishing Brownmark with Viacom’s attourney fees.

The judge went on to say South Park use of the video was “to lampoon the recent craze in our society of watching video clips on the internet that are — to be kind — of rather low artistic sophistication and quality.”


The judge also added that South Park even contributed to the viral video.

What What currently has over 44 million views on Youtube.

Check out the videos above to see Samwell and Butters.

Dec 8, 2011 12:30am PDT

Related Posts

More Like This