The actress appeared on the show with Shades of Blue costar Ray Liotta, and of course the Bravo host grilled them both for “Plead the Fifth”.
Andy asked the starlet:
“Jennifer, you said in an interview that you were proposed to five times in your life. Name someone who you turned down.”
Except that’s when Ray chimed in with a question to really make J.Lo blush:
Watch her reaction AND hear her response (below)!
[Image via Instagram.]