If this is fake, Bachelor alums Kaitlyn Bristowe, Shawn Booth, Carly Waddell, and Evan Bass did a phenomenal job fooling us!
Recently in Cape Cod for Whitney Bischoff‘s wedding, the foursome had a bit of a scare when returning to their recluse rental the night before the wedding.
And considering Carly is v v pregnant, we can’t imagine her stressing out this much if she didn’t need to be…
So, this is either an elaborate prank (great acting for reality stars!!) or something really freaky was actually happening!
Watch all the creepiness go down (below)!
Who had Carly’s phone? What did Shawn see? What was in the basement? How did Kaitlyn fall? Was someone in the house?
WE NEED ANSWERS, PPL.
P.S. around the 8:40 mark, we’re pretttty sure you can see the car keys in Shawn’s hands BUT WHO KNOWS ANYTHING ANYMORE.
[Image via YouTube.]