“We met and had our first date, but I was also dating multiple men. So does that count as our anniversary? Or does our anniversary count as the time we got engaged?”

TBH when you put it that way, we’re not exactly sure ourselves!
Either way, the lack of a clear-cut answer on this caused a huge misstep for Booth:

 “He actually forgot our anniversary last year.”

Yikes!! The fitness guru defended himself by pointing out the reality of their situation, no pun intended:

“He was like, ‘To be fair, you had just dumped a guy five minutes before deciding I guess I’ll pick this guy.'”

DAMN! But the 33-year-old immediately shot that excuse down, saying:

“‘Okay at the end of the day, you forgot our anniversary. You’re being a d**k right now. Just own that.'”

Well, there you have it!
Forgetting an anniversary isn’t reason enough for a breakup, but it is NOT a good sign.
Sigh. We can safely assume there’s probably more to the story but it is a shame these two couldn’t work it out!
[Image via Kaitlyn Bristowe/Instagram]