Crazy Twist In Teddi Mellencamp Affair Story! Horse Trainer Is Actually Married To MORE THAN ONE WOMAN!!!

If you thought this Teddi Mellencamp story had already gotten as shocking as it was going to, saddle up, y’all!

OK, here’s the story so far: Teddi surprised fans by announcing she was filing for divorce from Edwin Arroyave after 13 years of marriage. But then it came out that there was a rumor in the horse show community — yeah — that the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum had been cheating with her trainer! For months! Kind of an open secret sort of thing. It gets worse because that horse trainer — Simon Schröeder, who runs Schroeder Sporthorses — was ALSO married.

Word is his wife Karli Postel got suspicious when Simon missed the birth of their child to be in Florida at a horse show with Teddi. She then found proof of the cheating on his phone, and there was a blowup conversation in which they came clean and promised to stop. But they didn’t stop. And when Karli found out a few weeks back there was “an all-out brawl” at a competition. Not only that, the scorned wife reached out to Edwin! And that’s why Teddi filed!

Related: Teddi ‘Scared’ Of What Ex Will Do To ‘Come Out On Top’ In Divorce!

OK, that’s a lot, right? BUT THERE’S MORE!

According to a bombshell report in DailyMail.com on Thursday, this horse trainer isn’t just married… he’s married to MORE THAN ONE WOMAN!

Per the outlet Karli actually filed to annul her marriage to Simon last year! They obtained legal docs from the Ventura Superior Court from back in January 2023 in which Karli filed to declare the marriage legally invalid, citing “prior existing marriage or domestic partnership” as the reason. BIGAMY! She’s talking about BIGAMY!

After over three years of marriage, she filed to nullify the marriage because he was already married to someone else!

The inneresting thing is, technically Simon may not have been committing infidelity against Karli, at least in a legal sense, during his months-long affair with Teddi. Not if that marriage was never valid. Though clearly they’d thought it was and had been living as man and wife. Karli gave birth to their child in May 2024, so yeah — clearly still cheating, as we’ve heard from multiple sources.

But was he also cheating legally on someone else?? Who is this other wife? She wasn’t named in the filing, so that’s unclear now. Maybe just a legal snafu, who knows. But damn, it sounds like this guy is careless in his relationships with women, right??

[Image via WWHL/YouTube.]