Got A Tip?

Star Seeker

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives

Taylor Frankie Paul Claps Back After Mayci Neeley BLASTS Her 'Cult Followers' & Shades Mikayla Matthews' Skin Issues!

Taylor Frankie Paul Claps Back After Mayci Neeley BLASTS Her 'Cult Followers' & Shades Mikayla Matthews Skin Issues!

Taylor Frankie Paul does not stand for this!

The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives star is sticking up for her fans after Mayci Neeley called them “cult followers”!

If you missed it, on her Sinner Sundays Instagram over the weekend, Mayci opened up about the downsides of social media and fame, writing:

“Unfortunately it’s part of the job if you want to pursue it as a career. I got called a ‘baby daddy killer’ last week by one of Taylor’s cult followers so that’s fun”

Defending her stance against backlash, she doubled down:

“Someone who calls me a ‘baby daddy killer’ bc I defend Mikayla [Matthews] online. That’s psychotic behavior and I would consider that a cult follower. I don’t think all followers are cult followers. But if someone is going to bully & harass someone who isn’t on the same page as her? That’s what I would consider a cult follower. So I hope that’s not you.”

Well, word got back to Taylor, and now she’s throwing major shade!

In a new video posted earlier this week, the MomTok star complained:

“Where did ‘not everything is about Taylor’ energy go? Hate received has to be from my ‘cult following’? I don’t think so. Accept your own haters too.”

Called out!!!

Previously, Mayci responded to a fan who thought she was being rude about Taylor online, saying:

“Not everything is about Taylor lol”

Her own words coming back to haunt her. Hah!

Taylor didn’t stop there, though. She went on to seemingly take shots at Mikayla, who she has been feuding with, adding:

“In the meantime I have a cream I was recommended that helps with hurt feelings… reach out if needed.”

Damn!

Mikayla literally just posted about how she’s sick of people minimizing her chronic skin issues as just rashes. She’s been dealing with health flare-ups for YEARS! And now her co-star is joking about it?! Ouch!!!

Related: MASSIVE Selling Sunset Cast Shakeup! These OGs Were FIRED!

Mikayla, however, is already clapping back! She posted on TikTok:

“Don’t worry I think we are set on the creams. I would ask for recommendations on accountability, self awareness and not constantly projecting your anger and unhappiness onto the people who actually care about you, but something tells me she’s about as qualified to give advice on that as the ‘professionals’ she constantly references are to speak on my childhood SA.”

Shots fired!

In the caption of her post, Taylor continued to defend her fans, reflecting:

“It’s called support during my good and bad times, not cult. Those boundaries placed were for anyone but themselves.”

When a fan suggested Mayci wasn’t trying to be “mean” to Taylor, she reacted:

“They go from ‘not everything is about Taylor’ to I’m getting hate ‘must be from Taylor’s end’ which is it?”

They’re clearly all so fed up!!! Ch-ch-check out all the posts:

@stephwithdadeets

Taylor claps back at Mayci for calling out Taylor’s “cult folllower” but Mayci is not the only Momtoker to address Taylor’s ‘cult’ followers. ???? #taylorfrankiepaul #maycineely #secretlivesofmormonwives #tiktokdrama #greenscreen

♬ original sound – Stephwithdadeets

@stephwithdadeets

Mikayla responds to Taylor and says she all good on the creams. ???? #secretlivesofmormonwives #mikaylamatthews #taylorfrankiepaul #drama #greenscreen

♬ original sound – Stephwithdadeets

The drama never stops with these moms! Reactions, y’all?? Whose side are you on? Sound OFF in the comments!

[Image via Hulu]

CLICK HERE TO COMMENT
May 28, 2026 11:39am PDT