Got A Tip?

Star Seeker

Nancy Guthrie

Career Criminal Wanted For Alleged Kidnapping -- Just Miles From Nancy Guthrie's Home! Does It Have Anything To Do With Her Case?

FBI Agents Discover Suspicious Black Glove From Roadside Near Nancy Guthrie's House -- WHOA!

Oh, no! Police are on the lookout for an alleged kidnapper for an incident that happened in Nancy Guthrie‘s neighborhood!

The Pima County Sheriff’s Department shared a wanted poster for a 40-year-old woman named Coral Michelle Smith on Thursday, alleging that she’s connected to a kidnapping and aggravated assault case that happened on May 29, just about 7 miles away from Nancy’s home in the Catalina Foothills. Wow.

Related: Doctor, Therapist, And Attorney All Arrested In Child Sexual Abuse Sting

Court records viewed by TMZ show that the woman has a lengthy criminal history — including more kidnapping! She was found guilty and sentenced to prison in 2020 for an incident that involved kidnapping and drug charges, which were dropped.

In 2011, she was also found guilty of robbery. And other charges she’s been found guilty of over the years include criminal trespass, attempted vehicle theft, and disorderly conduct. See more information (below):

Career Criminal Wanted for Kidnapping -- Just Miles From Nancy Guthrie's Home! Does It Have Anything To Do With Her Case?
(c) Pima County Sheriff’s Department

But now the question on everyone’s mind: does this woman have anything to do with Nancy??

Sadly for those wanting answers, no, not at this time. Police have not indicated any connections. It appears like this is totally separate. Frankly, the PCSD seem nowhere near close to an answer about Nancy — so much so, Savannah Guthrie went back on the Today Show this week to plead for someone to call with information. We wish we had better news on that front.

How scary, though, for people still in that neighborhood. So unnerving to have another kidnapping case in the area!!!

Savannah Guthrie and her family are offering up to $1 million for information that leads to the recovery of Nancy Guthrie. NOTE: The family reward of up to $1 million will be paid only for recovery of Nancy Guthrie, consistent with FBI criteria for payment of its reward in this case: https://www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/nancy-guthrie
 
Authorities have encouraged anyone with information or tips to contact the FBI at 1-800-CALL-FBI, 88-CRIME or tips.fbi.gov. You can also contact the Pima County Sheriff’s office by calling 520-351-4900 or submitting a tip HERE.

[Image via FBI/Savannah Guthrie/Instagram]

CLICK HERE TO COMMENT
Jun 09, 2026 12:55pm PDT