VOTE: Which Spice Girl Do YOU Think Justin Timberlake Hooked Up With?

This goss is old — but it’s still totally spicy!
When Justin Timberlake confirmed on Ellen that he had once hooked up with a member of the Spice Girls, it sent our minds spinning back to the early 2000s.
Which Spice Girl was it? With whom did we see him? Did he ever talk about having a crush on anyone in particular? Did any of the girls gush about *NSYNC??
Video: Watch *NSYNC Reunite To Receive Their Star On The Walk Of Fame!
We have our own hunch… but we want to see who YOU think it was!
So vote AND tell us your theory in the comments (below)!